You are here

The Noose Around NOVA's Neck Tightens Just a Bit More

I stumbled upon an interesting nugget concerning NOVA's recent legal troubles. If you read this article on Nikkei BP Net [in Japanese], as a result of NOVA's loss in the Supreme Court, METI has tightened its interpretation of the Specific Commercial Transaction Law and is now not even allowing a "rational" reason to recalculate service costs when providing a refund.

Not only has NOVA lost in the Supreme Court, but METI has made extra sure that consumers can't be ripped off when canceling a contract. I don't know how this affects NOVA, but it's certainly not a good thing for them. METI's administrative order can be found here [PDF and Japanese legalese].

Japan: 

Comments

Thanks for the link! I'll be sure to read it after I comment, which means I'll probably say something that's already in the article. Anyway, I remember a bit back there being something in the press (Japanese or English?) about Nova claiming that METI officials had given the green light to their refund policy, which I thought odd, since it seemed like such an obvious farce, unless what the Nova spokesperson really meant was, "We had our return policy approved by the Ministry. Then we 'updated' it a bit. But, it still has the same title as the one approved by the Ministry! So what's the problem?"

Ken,
You're right. The early articles in the newspapers mentioned that NOVA thought it had the tacit agreement of METI. However, AFAIK that's all the coverage it got and the press never expanded upon it.

The February 16th Mainichi Shimbun put it this way:

NOVA統括本部の広報担当者は「検査では、外国人講師の採用や給与に関する資料提出、事情説明を求められたが、 会社として法律にのっとって運営している。特定商取引法違反という認識はない」と話している。解約時の精算については「精算式は経産省と打ち合わせて決め ている。都のガイドラインにも沿っており、契約書にも載せている。ただ現在、最高裁で審理しており、司法の決着を待ちたい」と説明した。

Who knows what NOVA and METI talked about or agreed upon, but my guess is that METI could not ignore the thousands of complaints about NOVA's refund policy and had to do something.


The significant problems we have cannot be solved at the same level of thinking with which we created them.
-Albert Einstein

Shawn


Copyright 2022 letsjapan.org